Below is a list of the top and leading Italian Restaurants in Sydney. To help you find the best Italian Restaurants located near you in Sydney, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Sydney’s Best Italian Restaurants:

The top-rated Italian Restaurants in Sydney are:

  • Macchiato Woodfire Pizza and Coffee Roasters – a casual Italian grill where you can enjoy classic wood-fired pizzas
  • Machiavelli – a longstanding family-owned and operated Italian restaurant
  • A Tavola – serves up your favourite regional Italian dishes
  • The Restaurant Pendolino – where you can satisfy your cravings for refined Italian staples
  • Alfredo – an authentic Italian restaurant and cocktail bar

Macchiato Woodfire Pizza and Coffee Roasters

Macchiato Woodfire Pizza and Coffee Roasters Italian Restaurant in Sydney

Macchiato Woodfire Pizza and Coffee Roasters starts off our list as one of the leading Italian restaurants in the capital. The restaurant is decorated with bare-brick walls and is rustic-chic in style. At this casual Italian grill, you will find your word-class wood-fired pizzas. For sure, you will also enjoy their signature coffees.

Truly, this is your escape from the busy and noisy streets of Sydney. You and your friends will surely enjoy your meals in this warm, fun, and lively dining space. Check out their menu today!


Italian Cuisine, Catering, Dine-in, Takeaway


Address: Shop 2/338 Pitt St, Sydney NSW 2000
Phone: (02) 9262 9525


“This has to be the best pizza and coffee house I have been to in Sydney. Very friendly and accommodating staff who managed to whip up breakfast way after breakfast time. Returned twice on the same day. A big shout out and hope to return in the coming weeks.” – Tom Iera


Machiavelli Italian Restaurant in Sydney

Machiavelli comes is a top-rated Italian restaurant in Sydney. It is a well-known and longstanding family-run establishment that serves up refined and first-class dishes that you definitely love. It comes as no surprise that Machiavelli is dubbed as Sydney’s favourite Italian restaurant.

In addition to that, they provide venues and room hire for all kinds of special occasions. A gift voucher from them also counts as a great gift to someone special. For your convenience, you can order online and have your pizzas and pasta right to your doorstep!


Italian Cuisine, Dine-in, Takeaway, Functions


Address: 123 Clarence St, Sydney NSW 2000
Phone: (02) 9299 3748


“Dining at Machiavelli’s last night brought back very many happy memories of dining at Romano’s many years ago. Last night’s experience was truly amazing with the quality of the fresh produce – the John Dory was cooked to perfection with the sides of creamed spinach and potato adding to the taste and presentation. Service was excellent, white table cloths and silver service and accompanied by the ambience of photos of our poor modern-day imitations of Machiavelli. The menu catered to all tastes and was wide in its coverage. One left captivated by the culinary and visual experience.” – Severino Milazzo

A Tavola

A Tavola Darlinghurst Italian Restaurant in Sydney

A Tavola comes next on our list. This top-class Italian restaurant is conveniently located in Darlinghurst. You can order mouth-watering regional Italian dishes here such as freshly handmade pasta. You will also find that the stylish restaurant is a great place for family gatherings and get-togethers with friends as long communal tables are set up here.

Since the restaurant was established in 2007, it has quickly built a reputation for its authentic Italian pasta. Just ask any of their loyal and regular diners!


Italian Cuisine, Dine-in


Address: 348 Victoria St, Darlinghurst NSW 2010
Phone: (02) 9331 7871


“Lovely atmosphere and the food is fantastic! One of my favourite Italian restaurants in Sydney!”- Rebecca Carlsen

The Restaurant Pendolino

The Restaurant Pendolino Italian Restaurant in Sydney

The Restaurant Pendolino is a must-visit Italian restaurant that you can find in the Strand Arcade. If you are in search of refined Italian stapes like handmade pasta, then this is the perfect place for you. Also, you will surely enjoy the peaceful ambiance in this plush space.

You will find that their regular customers come from Sydney’s business, fashion, and political elite. In addition to their world-class dishes, they stock up on leading brands of wine that will go perfectly well with your orders. Reserve your table today!


Italian Cuisine, Dine-in, Functions, Gift Vouchers


Address: Shop 100/412-414 George St, Sydney NSW 2000
Phone: (02) 9231 6117


“Exceptional food and service. Very attentive. Always a pleasure coming here for fine dining Italian! Highly recommend” – Nina Gao


Alfredo Authentic Italian Restaurant & Cocktail Bar in Sydney

Finally, Alfredo completes our list. This authentic Italian restaurant and cocktail bar is located in the prestigious Sydney Harbour Marriott Hotel.  Here, you can satisfy your cravings for traditional Italian cuisine in their warm and intimate space. As matter of fact, the restaurant’s walls are decorated with exposed brick and dates back to 1861.

Moreover, they make use of the freshest and finest ingredients to give you the most out of every bite. Their high-quality dishes come at competitive prices as well. Stop by Alfredo today for a one-of-a-kind dining experience!


Italian Cuisine, Dine-in, Cocktail Bar


Address: 16 Bulletin Pl, Sydney NSW 2000
Phone: (02) 9251 2929


“What an awesome day at Alfredo Authentic Italian Restaurant the atmosphere well I have never been to Italy but this Restaurant takes you there. The is, wonderful I would recommend Calamari crumbed with a white sauce, Penna Alla Maria just the right spices and the Spaghetti Marana with a rich Spaghetti sauce was truly amazing plus the Mussels were truly delicious these are only some of the delicious food served to us the other day.” – Karen Powyer