Below is a list of the top and leading Bagel Shops in Sydney. To help you find the best Bagel Shops located near you in Sydney, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Sydney’s Best Bagel Shops:

The top-rated Bagel Shops in Sydney are:

  • Brooklyn Boy Bagels – brings you real artisan NYC bagels
  • The Bagel Co. – serves up your favourite traditional bagels
  • The Bagel Place – offers freshly baked bagels and sandwiches
  • Bagel Bar & New York Deli – provides the perfect bagels for every celebration
  • Bagel Bakery Café – offer quality bagels, pies, and cakes

Brooklyn Boy Bagels

Brooklyn Boys Bagels in Sydney

First up, we have the popular Brooklyn Boy Bagels starting off our list. This top-notch bagel shop brings you the best in real-deal artisan NYC bagels like no other. As a matter of fact, Vogue named their bagels as the best bagels in Australia. According to the Sydney Food Bloggers Choice Awards, their bagels are the favourite ones among locals.

To bring you the best, they staff at Brooklyn Boy Bagels make use of time-worn traditional methods in preparing their bagels. You will find that each bite is chewy, malty, and truly flavorful. Order yours now!


Bagels, Beverages, Dine-in, Delivery, Wholesale, and more


Address: 19 Carrington Rd, Marrickville NSW 2204
Phone: 0414 022 911


“Great bagels, Pumpernickel is AMAZING, such a great flavour with many layers. Jalapeno and cheese were brilliant with just the right level of heat. I will be back!” – Jon Porter

The Bagel Co.

The Bagel Co in Sydney

The Bagel Co. is a must-visit bagel shop here in the city. You can find their shops located in Rose Bay and Surry Hills. The secret behind their popular bagels is that they use the freshest and finest ingredients in their family’s secret recipe.  As a matter of fact, their family recipe has been perfected for more than five decades now.

Truly, you will delight in each bite of their premium traditional bagels. Visit their website today to order your favourite bagel!


Bagels, Beverages, Dine-in, Online Ordering, Delivery Services


Address: Shop 3-4 / 475 Old, Old South Head Rd, Rose Bay NSW 2029
Phone: (02) 9371 7557


“I don’t have a photo of my bagels because I ate them too fast!! They have a great variety of bagels here and also sell mini ones. I got a rye bagel as well as a blueberry. They aren’t too dense, very nice and fluffy!!! The shop also sells muffins, wraps and even sushi, as well as coffees and milkshakes.” – Sarah Charles

The Bagel Place

The Bagel Place in Sydney

The Bagel Place comes next on our list. You can enjoy freshly baked bagels and mouth-watering sandwiches in this cosy café. In addition to that, you will be welcomed to the warm and welcoming atmosphere every time you drop by.

Moreover, they also make their bagels from scratch every day. To bring you the most flavourful bites, they only make use of the freshest ingredients from the market. In addition to that, you can call on them for catering solutions!


Bagels, Beverages, Sandwiches, Catering, Online Ordering, Dine-In


Address: 236 Pacific Hwy, Hornsby NSW 2077
Phone: (02) 9477 5111


“The best burger I’ve had in the world. My goodness. So good. Oh and they sell flying pigs ale. I’m done. This is my new place.” – Stephen David Anderson

Bagel Bar & New York Deli

Bagel Bar and New York Deli in Sydney

Bagel Bar & New York Deli is a go-to bagel shop here in the capital. Here, you can also find scrumptious New York-style bagels. Truly, this is the perfect place for you if you want to hang out and unwind with your family and friends.

Moreover, you will surely love the comfortable and welcoming atmosphere this place has. If you can’t make it to their store, you don’t need to fret. Browse through their website to shop and see what they have in store for you!


Bagels, Beverages, Dine-in, Online Ordering, and more


Address: Shop 1/84 Curlewis St, Bondi NSW 2026
Phone: 0418 113 513


“This place has only just opened and it’s by far the best bagel place in Bondi. The strawberry jam cream cheese bagel is the nicest bagel I’ve ever had. Staff are super friendly, the coffee is good and it’s a great little spot. Will be coming here a lot!” – Oliver Gallagher

Bagel Bakery Café

Bagel Bakery Cafe in Sydney

Finally, Bagel Bakery Café completes our list. If you visit Winston Hills, you must definitely pass by this well-known bagel shop. You can enjoy their delicious bagels in their outdoor dining area. You can also opt to order for takeaway.

Aside from bagels, they also serve mouth-watering pies, muffins. and cakes. Don’t forget to pair your pastries with their warm coffee. They are also known for their exceptional customer service. For a family-friendly and cosy café in the city, visit Bagel Bakery Café today!


Bagels, Pies, Cakes, Coffee, Dine-in, Takeaway


Address: 5/1 Caroline Chisholm Dr, Winston Hills NSW 2153
Phone: (02) 9686 8111


“We visit almost daily and are never disappointed! A genuine old-school bakery with a huge range of fresh cakes and pastries. Lin and her team are warm and efficient in equal measure.” – Kelly Cahalane